Yitro
Honor your father and
your mother so that your days may be long upon the soil which God, your God, is
giving you.
While I say that there are sins for which punishment
in this world is inevitable…I must furthermore make it clear that there are, on
the other hand, certain good deeds which are perforce requited in this world,
even though he that performs them is an unbeliever. These, I say, are three in number. The first of them is a loving demeanor toward
parents…A second is pity on animals…The third, again, is dealing honestly…
Saadya Gaon: (9th Century)
The exodus from
Samson Raphael Hirsch (19th Century)
The essence of “honor” is only when the parent enjoys
some benefit from the act of the child…But if a parent tells a child to do
something which does not bring some benefit to the parent, that is not included
in “honor” as commanded by the Torah, and the child is not required to defer
any kind of Torah prohibition in order to obey the parent.
Rashba(17th Century)
In (this) commandment, the focus is on the flow of the
generations. Will the generation that
bears the weight of the family’s existence now…preserve its identity by
acknowledging its origins through due honor to its parental generation?...We
will not go wrong if we deduce from the position of the parents-commandment as
the first of the commands with reference to fellow humans a certain preeminence
of the concern for the continuity of the extended family…
Waldemar Janzen (Contemporary)
Some Jewish thinkers, even thought they acknowledge
the validity of an autonomous ethics, nonetheless maintain that one should
comply with an ethical norm out of a desire to submit to the Divine Will rather
than to satisfy an ethical requirement...i.e. despite the fact that human
reason can apprehend and validate filial obligations as moral duties, a
religious believer should fulfill them not because of their intrinsic ethical
merits discernible by human reason or sentiment, but out of obedience to a
divine imperative…This explains why Judaism has no need for the Kierkegaardian doctrine of “the suspension of the ethical,”
which demands that whenever moral imperatives clash with religious commandments,
we must subordinate our ethical concerns to the higher authority of the
religious. Once God is defined as the
supreme moral authority, obedience to divine imperatives emerges as the highest
ethical duty…
Walter Wurzburger (20th
Century)
Alienation and identity play a central role in the
Exodus narrative. Both on the individual
and national levels, the experience of being a stranger and searching out one’s
past figure prominently in the process of psychological development. Moshe, the estranged son of his people, who
grew up in the house of the enemy and oppressor, did not share in the immediate
history of his people. In his privileged
status as a prince in Pharaoh’s house, a safe distance from the mud pits of his
enslaved brethren, he remained physically and culturally disconnected from
their experience. Yet he too knew on a
personal level the meaning of being a stranger in a foreign land, and the
struggle to separate from the surrounding culture in an attempt to establish an
independent identity. The correspondence
between his personal odyssey and that of the Israelites provided him with
intimate knowledge of their experience, making him uniquely suited to serve as
their leader.
Carolyn Peyser
(Contemporary)