Yitro
God spoke all these words, saying: “I
the Lord am your God who brought you out of the
20:1-3
Since this verse is formulated not as a declaration
but as a “commandment,” it does not mean, I am your but,” but “I shall be your
God.” In this manner it postulates as
the basis for our relationship to God that demand which our sages describe as
“accepting the yoke of the
Samson Raphael Hirsch (19th Century)
One may ask, how can “I am the Lord” be counted
among the Ten Statements, as God is the one who commands? Clearly, “I am the Lord” is neither a
positive nor a negative commandment. In
other words, “I am the Lord” is an introductory statement to that which
follows. That is, verse 3 is to be understood
as follows: “I am the Lord your God…who
commands you the following…
Ibn Ezra (11th Century)
The repetition of “spoke…saying…” suggests that God
rehearsed the words he was going to say to
Isaiah Horowitz (16th Century)
The repetition of “spoke…saying…”was added here in
order to teach that all these Ten Commandments were spoke in a single
utterance…
Rabbenu
Bachya (13th Century)
I alone am the Lord; I am the One responsible for
creating the material world, for creating egos, individuals, I am known to you
by tradition. I keep My
promise to remain your God. I am not to be worshipped through
intermediaries. I am to be prayed to
directly…and you can only worship me exclusively.
Sforno
(15th Century)
(God models for us)…If we have
found meaning and life in Judaism, we should be willing to speak about it in
front of others. Too many of
us are improperly shy. Furthermore, a
veneer of skepticism is often considered a sign of sophistication, even among
religious people…We should not be afraid to publicly say, “I believe in
God.” You would be surprised as how
often a simple declaration of faith elicits a positive response…
Yitzchak Buxbaum
(Contemporary)
Without
God, there can be no basis for Absolute Law or Morality. Without God, all morality becomes relative, a
matter of opinion. Without God, there is
no ultimate purpose to humanity. If the
natural world is the one objective reality, and there is no moral source beyond
nature, good and evil possess no objective reality. Without God there is no “wrong.”
Stuart
Altschuler (contemporary)